Thursday, March 10, 2016

Is there an 'African bioethics'?

Well, is there? There have been a number of published attempts to isolate what is different about African ways of identifying, analyzing and resolving ethical issues related to health and medicine. Usually there is talk of African communitarianism, solidarity and Ubuntu, to be contrasted with the typically ‘Western’ emphasis on personal autonomy. But as time goes on, this whole narrative seems more and more contrived and out of step with reality. We know autonomy has limits, and does not automatically trump other considerations in cases of moral conflict.  The stress on communal life and social harmony in African morality has similarly been oversold: contemporary ‘African life’ is not predominantly lived in villages led by traditional elders where communal problems are resolved by palabre under a baobab tree. That image is becoming increasingly quaint against the influences of colonialism and globalization, increased urbanization, digital communication, and the subsequent fraying of traditional community structures.
A couple of recent articles probe into what an African bioethics might mean. In Developing World Bioethics, Gerald Ssebunnya argues that the pursuit of a distinctly African bioethics is basically a fool’s errand. According to Ssebunnya, the whole idea that an African bioethics exists – or ought to – comes from Africanist philosophy and the desire to distance African philosophical thought from that of their past colonial masters and oppressors. Unfortunately, he writes, that meant falling back on what he calls ‘ethno-philosophy’, which consists of two main activities: (a) unreflectively recycling bits of common morality and (b) polemically talking about the nature and need of African philosophy rather than actually doing it. His remedy for what he calls this ‘sterility’ is for African bioethicists and other African stakeholders to work on the foundational, conceptual underpinnings of bioethics, and thereby contribute African elements to the ongoing global discussion about what makes health-related policies and practices ethical or unethical.
The article by Sirkku Hellsten in the Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics is about the role of philosophy in global bioethics, but also touches on the notion of regional flavors, like ‘African bioethics’. Using Henry Odera Oruka’s four types of African philosophy, she distinguishes four ways of philosophizing in bioethics worldwide: ethnophilosophy, philosophic sagacity, ideological philosophy, and professional philosophy. She makes a good attempt at describing the strengths and weaknesses of them all (and has the good grace to keep calling the first three 'philosophy'), but really, only professional philosophy contains something universal: the critical use of reason in examining and developing arguments. That is, and should be, the philosophy behind global bioethics. Hellsten seems undeterred by the fact that this universal method historically originated from the European Enlightenment, or that the method is known to be vulnerable to influence by cultural factors (or as she calls them, ‘biases’).
Where does this leave African bioethics? One option is that Africans keep producing bioethics informed by philosophical approaches Ssebunnya (and probably, in her heart of hearts, Hellsten) considers 'sterile.' Another option is that Africans are paradoxically meant to double-down on their Western philosophy, rather than avoid it, in order for African contributions to global bioethics to be born. Maybe this is where these two authors are going. Apply ‘universal method’ to African circumstances, stir. Will the resulting concoction be, in some way, African? 

Labels: , , ,

19 Comments:

Blogger jhon said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

1:41 AM  
Blogger Katherine Hayden said...

Good attempt at describing the strengths and weaknesses it is the professional philosophy which contains something universal, the critical use of reason in examining and developing arguments.
Academic essay writing services

2:48 AM  
Blogger Nicole R. Hill said...

Nice share. I think your website should come up http://write-my-essays.org/essayshark-com-review/ much higher in the search results than where it is showing up right now….

9:11 AM  
Blogger Mishra Suraj said...


We are only concerned in making our services better, and serving our customers nicely.
Hyderabad Movers and Packers
Bangalore Movers and Packers
http://www.bestpackers.org/category/packers-and-movers-hyderabad

2:26 AM  
Blogger Mishra Suraj said...


We shift your belongings quickly and efficiently by incorporating top-quality packaging material, dedicated staff, world-class technology.
Mumbai Movers and Packers
Pune Movers and Packers
http://www.bestpackers.org/category/packers-and-movers-mumbai

2:26 AM  
Blogger Mishra Suraj said...


We are here to shift your valuable and precious house hold goods to your destination.
Delhi Movers and Packers
Gurgaon Movers and Packers
http://www.bestpackers.org/category/packers-and-movers-delhi

2:26 AM  
Blogger sheetal 1984 said...

Thanks for such very great information. This is the best sites for proving such kinds of good information.
Examhelpline

2:00 AM  
Blogger jalpa prajapati said...

Really this is very great information sharing with us. Thanks lot.Examhelpline.in

2:28 AM  
Blogger jalpa prajapati said...


such a really amazing information thank you given to us..
CUSAT CAT Application Form 2017
AP ICET Application Form 2017
HBSE 12th Result 2017
MP SET Admit CArd 2017
careinfo.in
carebaba.com

6:01 AM  
Blogger Thomas pedro said...

Banks have a great deal less hazard loaning to individuals who have value in their property, particularly 20% value. Most sub prime property holders had almost no trouble renegotiating into a prime advance, getting an even lower rate and as a rule settling it for a long time too at a considerably more moderate installment. Car Title Loans Chicago

3:35 AM  
Blogger Thomas pedro said...

Despite everything you need to give the fundamental data yourself. Free programming accessible for duty accommodation utilizes an inquiry framework to get from all of you pertinent data. Once the data is given, the product places it in the best possible frame and summits it for your benefit to the IRS. It is that straightforward. Payday Loans

6:20 PM  
Blogger marko said...

This is a vital part of it and ought to be remembered when obtaining cash. Charge sum is set up as an escrow held by an outsider until the property arrangement is shut. From that point, the expense sum is discharged to a perceived saddling office. Payday Loans

10:22 PM  
Blogger marko said...

Home advances are constantly more in premium cost than you can get leaving your cash in the bank even on your online high premium records. When you consider capital development of your land resource much of the time you can get an awesome come back from putting resources into property. payday loans san-diego

11:28 PM  
Blogger buyket said...


تتعدد الشركات التي تقدم خدمات ىالتنظيف لاكن لا يمكن ان تكون كلها في نفس مستوي الجوده فان كنت من الباحثين عن جودة الشركه قبل اي شئ اخر فانصحة بزيارة احدي تلك الصفحات
شركة تنظيف مساجد بالرياض
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالخرج
شركة تنظيف بالخرج
والتي تقدم افضل خدمات التنظيف بالمنزل باعلي مستوي من الكفائه
شركة تنظيف منازل بالطائف


10:32 AM  
Blogger mustafiz rahman said...

Hi
I read your post.this article was very effective and helpful to us. thanks for sharing this amazing article. I am resently
posted at prince zamira,PZ Suits&leather belts is most important accessories of a man.I think always buckle belt,
watch and tie matching excellent.Everybody should try to follow this.

4:57 PM  
Blogger Herna Ismayanti said...

thanks for information Agen Qnc Jelly Gamat Di Tasikmalaya
Tips Manjur Mengatasi Nyeri Puting Payudara
Harga G-Sea Jelly Gamat

5:02 AM  
Blogger Juanitawong said...

Interesting article. Thanks for sharing this article. This is great to find a kind heart one here. Custom Essay Writing Service

9:00 AM  
Blogger William Kittrell said...

Don't get an idea even after reading the full article. But I found some curious doubts in my mind. Do my Essays

10:50 AM  
Blogger William George said...

I like your begin and end post. You have improved the condition than conventional work. much appreciation to you for the information you give, I after a short time expected that would express that you have Online Essay Help to an extraordinary degree so influencing and amazingly lighting up post. it helped me a wide measure. Extremely this is exceptionally awesome data imparting to us.

5:03 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home